Reviewed by Beverly "Splash" Abbott
(904) 887-8788

The Role of a Jury Consultant: How They Help Win Cases

May 6, 2025
Scales of justice symbol

A jury consultant is a trial strategist who helps attorneys understand how jurors think, so they can choose the right jury and present the case in a way that panel will accept. Jury consultants run pretrial research such as mock trials and focus groups. They build juror profiles and questionnaires, guide voir dire strikes, prepare witnesses, watch the jury during trial, and interview jurors after the verdict.

That is the textbook answer. In practice, the value of a jury consultant depends on who is sitting next to you and how long they stay. Beverly “Splash” Abbott has worked with trial lawyers since 2001 and contributed to more than $500 million in verdicts and settlements. The Trial Concierge provides jury consulting services to attorneys in 22 states, and Splash stays in the courtroom from voir dire through the reading of the verdict.

What Is a Jury Consultant?

A jury consultant, also called a trial consultant, applies research on human behavior, communication, and group decision-making to litigation. Many come from psychology, sociology, communication, or law. Their job is to replace guesswork about jurors with evidence: who is likely to favor your client, which themes land, and where your case is vulnerable before the other side finds it.

Jury consultants do not practice law or replace the trial lawyer. They work alongside the trial team as strategic advisors. The American Bar Association describes jury consultants as useful at nearly every stage, from early case assessment to post-trial interviews.

The Trial Concierge approaches the role a little differently. Beverly “Splash” Abbott is the only trial consultant in the country with a medical degree. That background matters most in the catastrophic injury, product liability, and medical negligence cases where jurors have to understand complex evidence before they can award fair damages.

What Does a Jury Consultant Do?

Most of the work falls into five stages, and a strong consultant connects all five so that what you learn early shapes what you do in front of the jury.

  • Pretrial jury research: Mock trials, focus groups, and community attitude research test themes, evidence, and damages with people who resemble your jury pool.
  • Jury selection and voir dire: Consultants build juror profiles, write supplemental questionnaires, and help decide which jurors to strike for cause or with peremptory challenges.
  • Witness preparation: Fact and expert witnesses learn to testify clearly, stay composed under cross-examination, and connect their testimony to the case theme.
  • In-court monitoring: During trial, the consultant watches juror reactions and helps the team adjust strategy while there is still time to change it.
  • Post-trial juror interviews: After the verdict, interviews reveal what persuaded the jury and sharpen strategy for the next case.

Each stage is covered in more detail below. Not every consultant offers all five, and that difference is worth asking about before you hire anyone.

Pretrial Research and Case Strategy

Person using a computer

A trial consultant’s work starts long before jury selection. Strong case analysis identifies the facts to lead with, the weaknesses to address first, and the narrative that holds up when the defense attacks it.

Focus Groups, Mock Trials, and Data Collection

Before jury selection, mock jury services and focus groups help you gather real feedback. Through mock trials, focus groups, and pretrial research, case themes can be tested before they go to court. The research shows how jurors may respond to the evidence and to witness testimony, so you can shape your trial strategy around what actually persuades people rather than what persuades lawyers.

A focus group is exploratory and conversational, and it is useful early, when themes are still forming. A mock trial is a fuller simulation with openings, testimony, and deliberations, and it is useful closer to trial when you need to pressure-test the whole presentation. When the stakes justify it, our team pairs this work with broader survey and data analysis to validate what small groups reveal.

Case Themes and Damages

Research findings feed directly into the case theme, the simple story that carries the case from voir dire to closing. Theme work also runs into damages. Jurors may award substantial verdicts when they are convinced a defendant acted with disregard for safety, and the presentation has to justify that number without looking like overreach. Splash helps attorneys find that line.

Jury Selection and Voir Dire

The importance of your jury selection strategy cannot be overstated. Voir dire is the only time you hear from jurors directly, and many of them will not volunteer the attitudes that matter most. A jury consultant brings juror profiles built from the pretrial research and helps you spot hidden bias that a single attorney, focused on asking questions, can easily miss.

Juror Questionnaires

Supplemental juror questionnaires go past demographics into experiences, beliefs, and decision-making patterns. At The Trial Concierge, questionnaires are completed in the courtroom, and our team brings all of the necessary equipment and makes the copies, so the process stays seamless for the court and the judge’s staff.

Strikes and Real-Time Analysis

During questioning, Splash tracks responses, body language, and group dynamics, flagging jurors whose stated positions do not match their instincts. That live read helps you use cause challenges and peremptory strikes on the jurors who pose the most risk to your client, rather than relying on gut feel.

Witness Preparation and Trial Communication

Jury consultants do much more for their clients than help with the jury. Splash has made a name for herself in witness preparation and is flown across the country specifically for this step. Some witnesses seem less credible in front of a jury when they are nervous or lack confidence, even when they are telling the truth.

Coaching Witnesses to Build Credibility

Preparation focuses on clarity, composure, and consistency: explaining complex information in plain language, handling hostile cross-examination, and keeping testimony aligned with the broader case theme. Expert witnesses get the same attention, because a qualified expert who cannot connect with a jury can hurt a case as much as a weak one.

Trial Graphics and Presentation

How evidence looks often decides how well it is understood. The Trial Concierge builds trial graphics and presentations that simplify medical, technical, and financial evidence so jurors can follow it without effort.

In-Court Monitoring Through the Verdict

This is where most jury consultants stop. Many hand over a juror profile after voir dire and move on to their next case. Splash stays through the verdict, sitting with the trial team from opening statements to the reading of the verdict.

That continuity lets the team react while it still matters. If a witness lands poorly, if jurors react to a piece of evidence in an unexpected way, or if the defense opens a new line of attack, the strategy can be adjusted the same day. In long trials against well-funded defendants, that daily feedback is often where the real work happens.

Post-Trial Analysis and Juror Interviews

After the verdict, juror interviews reveal which evidence carried the most weight, which witnesses jurors trusted, and how deliberations unfolded. Jury consultants and trial consultants also review verdict outcomes against the pretrial research. That feedback improves strategy on the cases that follow, whatever the result of this one.

Jury Consultant vs. Trial Consultant: What Is the Difference?

Statue of Justice

The two titles are often used interchangeably. In general, “jury consultant” emphasizes juror research and jury selection, while “trial consultant” covers the broader scope of case strategy, witness preparation, presentation, and courtroom support.

You do not have to choose between them. The Trial Concierge provides both services to your legal team, so you have one consultant who knows your case from the first focus group to the final juror interview.

When Should You Hire a Jury Consultant?

Earlier is almost always better. Bringing a jury consultant in during case assessment lets research shape your themes, damages strategy, and settlement position before positions harden. Consultants are also brought in closer to trial for focused jury research, voir dire, and courtroom support when that is what a case needs.

Jury consultants are most valuable in high-stakes litigation where the exposure is large, the evidence is complex, or the defendant is a well-funded corporation, health system, or insurer. Even seasoned attorneys benefit from an objective eye and real data before they commit to a trial strategy.

How The Trial Concierge Is Different

Many trial consulting firms offer research and jury selection. Few offer the combination that Beverly “Splash” Abbott brings to a trial team.

A medical degree in the room. Splash is the only trial consultant in the country with a medical degree, which lets her read medical records, follow clinical decision-making, and translate complex evidence for jurors.

A partner through the verdict. She stays in the courtroom from voir dire through the reading of the verdict, the stretch most consultants miss.

A partnership model. For the cases she takes, Splash works on contingency, so her outcome is tied to yours. There is also a fee schedule built to meet a range of case needs.

A proven track record. Her results include more than $500 million in verdicts and settlements, the largest verdict against Ford ($56.7 million), and the largest verdict in Spokane history ($42 million).

Splash’s calendar is built around active, high-value litigation in 22 states, and she is selective about the cases she accepts. Attorneys who have tried a case with her rarely go looking for another consultant.

Work With Beverly “Splash” Abbott

Beverly “Splash” Abbott has supported trial lawyers since 2001 and is currently working on matters valued from $200 million to $1 billion. Her approach combines pretrial research, voir dire strategy, witness preparation, and courtroom presence through the verdict, with the credibility of the only medical degree in the field.

If you are carrying a high-stakes civil case and want a consultant invested in the outcome as much as you are, reach out to discuss your case.

Frequently Asked Questions About Jury Consultants

What does a jury consultant do during trial?

During trial, a jury consultant watches juror reactions to testimony, evidence, and arguments, and gives the trial team daily feedback. That lets attorneys adjust witness order, emphasis, or themes while there is still time. Many consultants leave after jury selection, but Beverly “Splash” Abbott stays in the courtroom through the reading of the verdict.

What is the difference between a jury consultant and a trial consultant?

The titles overlap. A jury consultant usually focuses on juror research and jury selection, while a trial consultant also covers case strategy, witness preparation, presentation, and courtroom support. The Trial Concierge provides both services, so one consultant follows the case from early research through the verdict.

When should an attorney hire a jury consultant?

As early as possible. Involving a jury consultant during case assessment lets research shape themes, damages strategy, and settlement decisions before they are locked in. Consultants can also join closer to trial for mock trials, voir dire, and in-court support, but early involvement usually gives the research more room to influence the case.

How much does a jury consultant cost?

Cost depends on the scope of the work, such as the number of mock trials, the length of trial, and travel. The Trial Concierge has a fee schedule designed to meet a range of case needs, and for the cases she takes, Splash works on a contingency basis so her compensation is tied to the outcome.

Do jury consultants work on civil or criminal cases?

Jury consultants work on both. The Trial Concierge focuses on high-stakes civil litigation, including catastrophic injury, product liability, and medical negligence cases against well-funded defendants, for trial lawyers in 22 states.

About the Author

Beverly “Splash” Abbott

Founder, The Trial Concierge | RN, MBA, LNCC

Beverly “Splash” Abbott has helped trial lawyers plan, prepare for, and win complex civil cases since 2001. She is the only trial consultant in the country with a medical degree and stays in the courtroom from voir dire through verdict. Her results include more than $500 million in verdicts and settlements.

Back to Blog
From Voir Dire to Verdict

Contact us today and experience what makes us unique.

At The Trial Concierge, we deliver the results you are seeking. We provide crucial guidance and prepare for discovery, mediation, trial, jury, or settlement.

Follow Us
Call Us Today
Schedule Consultation